Lost in translation (Part 6)

You may also like...

38 Responses

  1. Interstellar says:

    Hi All,
    Pleased to discuss with you again after the summer break.
    Apologies in advance if you’ve recieved this same message 2-3 times but for some reason my message won;t go through. Hopefully, it will this time.

    Arwyn-That’s not how Albert’s “amnesia” is mentioned in the novel and especially not in the original circa 1970-1980 manga series. It’s far more intricate than that. Apparently, the anime series would resort to more simplistic interpretations as it was intended for a younger (childhood) audience. In both the manga and especially the novel, Albert’s medical condition is more akin to a post-traumatic stress disorder or perhaps what medical scientists and psychiatrists as well as neurologists would refer to “Retrograde Amnesia (RA)”. I would refrain using Wikipedia as a credible source since there are tons of scholarly research found in highly acclaimed, double peer-reviewed academic journals, many of which are archived in Google Scholar (and elsewhere) and then you’ll be re-directed to the actual scientific/academic source upon request. On the other hand, Wikipedia has zero academic and scientific credibility. This constitutes common knowledge amongst all of us within the academic and scientific cosmos. It’s simply a useful “lay-person’s” tool for some shallow online pseudo-research and nothing more than that. Not a single university and scientific institution would ever resort to Wikipedia as a credible source, at least not one which respects its academic expertise and reputation. If I had used Wikipedia even once for my PhD, I would have failed miserably and rightfully so. In addition, we shouldn’t forget that back in the early 1900s, not much was known about brain and memory functions/ disorders. Therefore, medical knowledge surrounding Albert’s condition would have certainly been muddled. Even nowadays, brain function and disorders continue to be a “terra incongnita” within the medical and neurological field.
    I won’t go into further details as this forum is a CCFS fanbase and not a medical or academic one. There is an interesting reference page provided by the NHS (it’s the National HealthCare System of the United Kingdom) which briefly and simplistically delineates certain aspects and traits of the “amnesia” phenomenon: https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/memory-loss-amnesia/
    http://www.winchesterhospital.org/health-library/article?id=917219

    Without jumping to conclusions, Albert’s condition appears to constitute an “amalgamation” of a physical/brain disorder as well as severe psychological trauma due to him almost losing his life during the war-related bomb explosion on the train and most possibly also due to the devastation he felt after the death of his sister who meant the world to him. Unlike Candy, Albert kept his feelings and sorrow all bottled up and irrevocably this has a significant impact upon his physical health as psychological well-being. It was wise and astute of the author, Keiko Nagita, to give ample time for Albert to heal. It took him almost two years to recover and regain his memory which doesn’t seem unrealistic or “Hollywood-like” at all.

    Regards to All, Interstellar

    Ms Puddle-If your promotion is true, congrads from me too. I got one myself a few months ago and yeap.. it sure does mean a hell of a load of additional work and responsibilities. I think promotions are just a euphemism for stacking more workload on our backs like a mule. Talk about sugar-coating the pill. huh..

  2. Interstellar says:

    Hi Ms Puddle, I’m trying to post a response but it’s not coming across for some reason. I’ll try again and pardon if you get 2-3 same messages from me.
    Interstellar

    • Interstellar says:

      Here’s the post I was talking about but I had to remove some links because they may be the cause of the inaccessibility issue:

      Hi Arwyn-That’s not how Albert’s “amnesia” is mentioned in the novel and especially not in the original circa 1970-1980 manga series. It’s far more intricate than that. Apparently, the anime series would resort to more simplistic interpretations as it was intended for a younger (childhood) audience. In both the manga and especially the novel, Albert’s medical condition is more akin to a post-traumatic stress disorder or perhaps what medical scientists and psychiatrists as well as neurologists would refer to “Retrograde Amnesia (RA)”. I would refrain using Wikipedia as a credible source since there are tons of scholarly research found in highly acclaimed, double peer-reviewed academic journals, many of which are archived in Google Scholar (and elsewhere) and then you’ll be re-directed to the actual scientific/academic source upon request. On the other hand, Wikipedia has zero academic and scientific credibility. This constitutes common knowledge amongst all of us within the academic and scientific cosmos. It’s simply a useful “lay-person’s” tool for some shallow online pseudo-research and nothing more than that. Not a single university and scientific institution would ever resort to Wikipedia as a credible source, at least not one which respects its academic expertise and reputation. If I had used Wikipedia even once for my PhD (my expertise lies within biochemistry/neurological phenomena), I would have failed miserably and rightfully so. In addition, we shouldn’t forget that back in the early 1900s, not much was known about brain and memory functions/ disorders. Therefore, medical knowledge surrounding Albert’s condition would have certainly been muddled. Even nowadays, brain function and disorders continue to be a “terra incongnita” within the medical and neurological field.
      I won’t go into further details as this forum is a CCFS fanbase and not a medical or academic one. There is an interesting reference page provided by the NHS (it’s the National HealthCare System of the United Kingdom) which briefly and simplistically delineates certain aspects and traits of the “amnesia” phenomenon: [www.nhs.uk/conditions/memory-loss-amnesia][www.winchesterhospital.org/health-library/article?id=917219]

      Without jumping to conclusions, Albert’s condition appears to constitute an “amalgamation” of a physical/brain disorder as well as severe psychological trauma due to him almost losing his life during the war-related bomb explosion on the train and most possibly also due to the devastation he felt after the death of his sister who meant the world to him. Unlike Candy, Albert kept his feelings and sorrow all bottled up and irrevocably this has a significant impact upon his physical health as psychological well-being. It was wise and astute of the author, Keiko Nagita, to give ample time for Albert to heal. It took him almost two years to recover and regain his memory which doesn’t seem unrealistic or “Hollywood-like” at all.

      Regards, Interstellar

      • Ms Puddle says:

        Hello Interstellar, sorry I missed your comments. I was so busy at work until just now. I have approved your previous comments (yes, comments with multiple links are regarded as spam), so I’m going to remove this duplicate soon. 😉

  3. Arwyn says:

    From what I’ve read of CCFS, I never got the impresson that Candy was angry at Albert per se. I call it mock-angry, pouting, flirting like a jealous girlfriend even. I even saw her tone as a bit too late teen, juvenile even, and Albert humors her. It’s actually very in character for Candy (and one of the reasons I am not particularly fond of her, I don’t like giggling/sobbing teens, I’m waaaaay over that drama phase).
    By the way, I tried posting another reply three times hours ago, but it’s not up yet. Has it been rejected by the system because it containes YouTube links?

  4. Avon says:

    Hello again, Ms Puddles!

    Definitely looking forward to your subsequent artwork and thoughtful analysis surrounding the controversial CCFS. It’s most appreciated that you endeavour to find some time to write such enjoyable material for us all even though your time-frame is so hectic. If I correctly recall (do correct me if I’m wrong here..), you’ve been promoted in your job. Congratulations for that! It’s certainly well-deserved!

    Of-course, job promotions, albeit warmly welcomed, constitute a further stress on invaluable free-time, nonetheless. There’s a saying (I don’t recall it verbatim) that with each promotion comes tons of additional workload, hence, making it a bit of a mixed-blessing. I would consider that we all have experienced this as everyone in this forum derive from highly intelligent and well-educated backgrounds. I have noticed that the pro-Albert fandom does share that common denominator without intending to be invidious to the other CC/CCFS fandom, apparently. What matters the most is that our long-term time and effort in completing our academic education and delving into our highly demanding jobs offers us satisfaction, joy and pleasure even though we get exhausted from time-to-time.

    Resuming to the CCFS, I’ve read yours and Alex’s views on the Candy-Albert interpersonal interaction and I’ll simply reiterate that these aforesaid perspectives are inspiring and intelligent. Both of you have delved so deeply into every nook and cranny of this novel which has sparked so much controversy amongst the CC/CCFS fandom.

    Moreover, your point about Candy being hostile to Albert after his debut as WAA is striking in the least. Doesn’t it remind you a bit of her initial hostility against Terry back at St Paul’s School? One could construe that her negativity constitutes a deep-rooted defence mechanism against her own passions and intimate emotions. She wasn’t hostile, however, against Anthony. However, her emotive response to Terry and Albert bear some interesting similarities.

    That said, I’ll agree with you that her act of defiance in appearing in the same photo with Albert would have certainly raised a few eyebrows amongst the Ardlays-needless to mention the Lagans. However, I also give credit to Albert for keeping his own ground and not yielding to Candy’s tantrums, especially during their correspondence when he clearly explains to her that he respects her decision to return and work at Pony’s Home but she must also respect his firm decision to be committed to his job which he confesses to Candy that he enjoys to the fullest. The two of them have an interchange of individuality as well as their own personal needs. This is quite typical of two people who are immensely attracted to one another.

    Have to head back to work and my research (resuming the long hours at the university library after a long day’s work, I’m afraid..).

    Talk to you again soon and truly looking forward to your excellent work.

    Best Regards,
    Avon

    P.S. Please ignore typos as I’m typing as fast as lightning, Lol.

    • Interstellar says:

      Glad to hear from you again, Avon! The summer was a bit of a hiatus for all of us here at this forum, right? I agree with what you’re saying about the Miami incident and TBH I don’t really think it’s that significant anyway because no one really wanted to be there in the first place. That’s why Keiko Nagita simply brushed it away and moved on to further significant stuff.

      Talk to you again soon!
      Interstellar

      • Ms Puddle says:

        Hello Interstellar, I did go through the duplicates but decided to just remove one. They are not entirely the same, so if you don’t mind, I’ll leave them alone.

        Congratulations to your job promotion by the way! 🍾 🍻 Despite the new responsibilities and workload, I’m sure you’ll succeed. 😊

        About the Miami incident, I actually think it’s rather important, precisely because Archie and Madam Elroy didn’t go. You know Albert could have gone there with Georges without involving Candy.

        In the old novel the hotel opening was in Chicago, I was told. In CCFS Nagita moved it so far away from everyone, and why did Candy have to go, really?

        I think somehow Albert convinced her. Maybe she wanted to be with him too. After all, ever since she moved back to Pony’s Home they lived far apart from each other.

        Albert must have planned to use his power to make Sarah Lagan apologize and clear Candy’s name in front of the guests. I don’t think Candy knew about this beforehand.

        I have a feeling that something significant had happened during the trip. In my own imagination I think Albert’s confession took place not long after that trip. Come to think of it, the Miami ‘family picture’ was displayed in the study in their present, so it was an irrefutable clue of who Anohito was.

    • Ms Puddle says:

      Hello Avon, I’m trying to go through the comments to make sure I didn’t miss any of them. Not that I’m complaining. 😉 On the contrary, all the latest comments have put smiles on my face. The positive feedback is fuel to me to keep updating. Many thanks again for your kind words and encouragement, Avon. 😍🤗

      Yes, Avon, the promotion happened early this year, and thank you for noticing. I don’t remember I actually mentioned it lol… You’re absolutely right about it being a mixed-blessing. It comes with more work and responsibilities. I did welcome it though because it was nonetheless a recognition of my hard work. Not to mention the satisfaction that resulted when I had accomplished something in the new role. Anyway, enough of “bragging” 😅, but I must say I’m amazed at how many pro-Albert fans are professionals or have well-educated background. I’m sure Avon you’re among them yourself. 👩‍🎓

      Back to CCFS, about Candy’s odd behavior when she was alone with Albert, oh yes I share your sentiments. She was like the female Terry, acting like a troll, no matter how sincerely Albert had apologized (in Japanese it is obvious he had asked for forgiveness more than once). The funny thing is that she seemed proud of being the “upper hand”, and she even said so in her letter to Georges.

      About her act of defiance, I suppose some guests would have wondered why she didn’t want to stand next to her adoptive father. After all, who didn’t want to take that coveted spot in the picture?

      I like your analysis of how Albert and Candy kept their own grounds while being immensely attracted to each other. I won’t add to your excellent comment other than that Candy acted like a girlfriend already and Albert undoubtedly knew how upset she would be when he could not fulfill her birthday wish. He basically admitted the significance of his presence.

  5. Fay says:

    Hello, Arwyn. Welcome to this blog. Since you are an Albert fan, I’m sure you will find many interesting information here about your (our) favourite CC character. Here you can find the English translation of CCFS which is almost complete, except for the epilogue, and a lot of answers to your questions. You said you left two Candy forums because you were disappointed. I can very well imagine why, and I think I also know to what forums you refer to. Please correct me if I’m wrong. Are you Greek? Your name sounds familiar to me. In the Greek CC forum there was a member called Arwyn, who was a great fan of Albert. That member isn’t active anymore there, so I suspected it must be you. Too many coincidences… Of course I may still be wrong, so in that case, I’m sorry. Anyway, you are a welcome addition to this wonderful blog. And there’s nothing wrong with being especially Albert’s fan and not Candy’s. Many of us think that way too. I guess Nagita created an unforgettable male character with a complex and intriguing personality. It’s hard not to be attracted to him.

    • Arwyn says:

      Hi Fay! Yes, yes… I am that infamous Arwyn. 😁 I left the fandom years ago, moved to other things, but lately an actor that could so much be a live Albert made me, er, relapse LOL. If you search on YouTube for Luke Mitchell and especially °John & Charlotte – Safe and Sound”, well, it was like seeing Albert and Candy (such a pity ‘The Tomorrow People’ was cancelled after just one season, amazing show!). Add Luke with a full beard in the series Blindspot (as Roman) and… I saw Albert all the time😍. One thing lead to another and…. I came across this blog. Ms Puddle has such excellent analyses that I’m spending hours reading, good when you are a shift doctor on long duty day in a public hospital 😉.
      I’m not in touch with any other Candy place and hardly any fellow fan. Here I came just to congratulate MsP really and find that Miami thing that has always bugged me.

      • Ms Puddle says:

        Arwyn, once again, welcome to my blog. 🤗 Glad to hear that you’re willing to come back to the fandom that you left some time ago. Fay, sounds like you have been active in that Greek forum for a long time? 😉

        Thanks again for your kind words and compliments, Arwyn! You can’t believe how I struggled with my time and felt like giving up altogether. 😔 Anyway, thank you. 😊

        So you’re a medical doctor? I’m curious if the amnesia plot in the story makes sense to you?

        • Arwyn says:

          I’m a… tooth doctor actually, dentist. 😁 I’ve read articles on amnesia and I’ve come to the conclusion that the “hit my head, cannot remember my name” thing is a Hollywood invention. Head trauma is complicated and so is the mechanisms of memory.

          https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amnesia

          In the amazing film Recovery (with David Tennant) the character suffers not only memory loss, but change of personality and twist of behavior. It was based on medical facts and true cases. So… is Albert a realistic amnesiac? No. Does his amnesia serve Mizuki’s plot? Yes. 😉

        • Interstellar says:

          Hi Ms Puddles, and Arwyn-That’s not how Albert’s “amnesia” is mentioned in the novel and especially not in the original circa 1970-1980 manga series. It’s far more intricate than that. Apparently, the anime series would resort to more simplistic interpretations as it was intended for a younger (childhood) audience. In both the manga and especially the novel, Albert’s medical condition is more akin to a post-traumatic stress disorder or perhaps what medical scientists and psychiatrists as well as neurologists would refer to “Retrograde Amnesia (RA)”. I would refrain using Wikipedia as a credible source since there are tons of scholarly research found in highly acclaimed, double peer-reviewed academic journals, many of which are archived in Google Scholar (and elsewhere) and then you’ll be re-directed to the actual scientific/academic source upon request. On the other hand, Wikipedia has zero academic and scientific credibility. This constitutes common knowledge amongst all of us within the academic and scientific cosmos. It’s simply a useful “lay-person’s” tool for some shallow online pseudo-research and nothing more than that. Not a single university and scientific institution would ever resort to Wikipedia as a credible source, at least not one which respects its academic expertise and reputation. If I had used Wikipedia even once for my PhD, I would have failed miserably and rightfully so. In addition, we shouldn’t forget that back in the early 1900s, not much was known about brain and memory functions/ disorders. Therefore, medical knowledge surrounding Albert’s condition would have certainly been muddled. Even nowadays, brain function and disorders continue to be a “terra incongnita” within the medical and neurological field.
          I won’t go into further details as this forum is a CCFS fanbase and not a medical or academic one. There is an interesting reference page provided by the NHS (it’s the National HealthCare System of the United Kingdom) which briefly and simplistically delineates certain aspects and traits of the “amnesia” phenomenon: https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/memory-loss-amnesia/
          http://www.winchesterhospital.org/health-library/article?id=917219

          Without jumping to conclusions, Albert’s condition appears to constitute an “amalgamation” of a physical/brain disorder as well as severe psychological trauma due to him almost losing his life during the war-related bomb explosion on the train and most possibly also due to the devastation he felt after the death of his sister who meant the world to him. Unlike Candy, Albert kept his feelings and sorrow all bottled up and irrevocably this has a significant impact upon his physical health as psychological well-being. It was wise and astute of the author, Keiko Nagita, to give ample time for Albert to heal. It took him almost two years to recover and regain his memory which doesn’t seem unrealistic or “Hollywood-like” at all.

          Regards, Interstellar

      • Fay says:

        Arwyn, you made me curious about this real life Albert. I’ll be sure to check what you suggested. One of our friends in this blog, Alex, suggested once some real persons, most of them actors, who might impersonate several CC characters. It was rather interesting, although the original ones remain unsurpassed.
        If you like, you can visit the Greek CC forum. I assure you the atmosphere there is much more civilized and pleasant ever since the crazy Terry fans left and created their own forum. There you can also find the Greek translation of CCFS based on the English one which is on this blog. (Both translations are my own humble and amateur work, the English translation aided and abetted by my wonderful friend Ms. Puddle.) I’ll be glad to see you there too.

        Ms. Puddle, I can’t say I have been in the Greek forum for such a long time. Arwyn was a member there long before I discovered it, and I have read many of her comments dated about nine or ten years ago. I am rather a novice there, having registered a little more than a year ago, and sadly many girls who wrote there are now gone, just like Arwyn. Many Terry fans wrote in that forum back then and used to ridicule Albert and sometimes even insult those who liked him. As a result, there were many conflicts between Albert fans and Terry fans, and maybe that’s why a lot of members (Albert fans too) left that forum. I don’t think I would have stayed myself under those circumstances. Fortunately, the “fanatic” Terry fans created their own paradise in which Anohito is Terry. As you can see, Terry has a lot of crazy fans in my country too.

        • Arwyn says:

          Looooong cynical post… 😋 It’s Friday night after all.

          Nah… I’ve said all there was to say in the Greek forum, Fay. Nothing new really. I’ve always been a strong Albert fan and only that, ever since I saw him in the anime, standing lost in front of the hospital balcony door, his eyes a piercing blue. Sure I had watched all episodes before, but I was not that hooked, science fiction was my thing, not Candy Candy. Terry? He got on my nerves and he still does, I absolutely despise the “rude bad boy, but oh he’s got a good heart deeeeeep inside” type. Anyway, what I mean is that the only character I understand, like and can relate to all in all is Albert. Even Candy is off for me, a fake, too good to be true, a Mary Sue. The whole story is a blatand mimicry (to plagiarism levels…) of Daddy Long Legs and Anne of Green Gables, with those originals being far better. Nagita/Mizuki did not invent the wheel, just copied it and added extra Japanese pain and suffering. And in typical Japanese way (and for all the Yen she could gain), she gave an Anohito final story. -shakes head- So… just one character out of all, not my favorite anime/manga, flamed for my pro Albert views, daring to criticize God Terry, yup, I was not popular, I left for greener pastures. 😎

          And about two years ago, I see actor Luke Mitchell, both in Blindspot and The Tomorrow People. Check the following videos on YouTube:
          Warning… they contain violence.

          John Young | Rebel Leader
          john x jedikiah 》 keep your demons on a leash
          Jane and Roman | Dynasty

          He sooo reminded me of Albert, he could play Albert. Oh yes. 😍

          One final thing: being away so long, coming back made all the anachronisms and impossibilities of CC seem ridiculous. The simplest thing is… did Nagita never own a map?? A globe?? Is Geography not taught in Japan?? Does she know where lake Michigan really is? Chicago? .. London? … ITALY?!?! Erm… the Atlantic Ocean, that wide strip of water?! Yes, it’s a children’s fairytale, but sending a patient from Italy to Chicago in 1915ish?! We don’t even do it in 2018!!!!!!

          There… I blew up my steam. 😤 😄😄😁😶😶😶😁

        • Ms Puddle says:

          Hello Fay, it must have been a relief to many fans in that Greek forum that some crazy fans had left to create their own forum to praise their favorite hero. I mean every fan has his/her rights to express his/her thoughts and opinions, but freedom of speech doesn’t mean s/he can belittle others who don’t share their sentiments. Sigh…

  6. Arwyn says:

    Hi girls! My my, I can barely keep up with you two, LOL! Replies faster than Superman! 😂 Anyway, thanks for the info, it was right under my nose and couldn’t find it, ugh!
    So… the people in the photo are Neil, Eliza, Mrs.Leagan, Albert, George, Candy, Mary and Stewart… at least. Hmmm… do you think that the arranging order is how I mention them? I don’t think Albert would like to be surrounded by Leagans, just have them sideways. And Candy, well, being between George and Mary, she is an Ardlay, just not center and right by Albert. I believe she did not feel comfortable to do that yet, stand publicly by Albert I mean.
    More thoughts later, need to collect them fist. Hugs!

  7. Arwyn says:

    Thank you both Ms Puddle and Avon for your welcome and your lengthy replies! Real life prevents me from replying myself in detail, sorry! Raincheck? And could you please direct me to the exact passage of CCFS where the Miami scene takes place? I don’t remember if it was a chapter or a letter. Is it a letter of the epiloge we have not the translation of yet in this blog? I have a rough translation of it from long ago somewhere in some hard drive 😊 , but… I can’t find it and it’s bugging the heck out of me.

    • Avon says:

      No bother. I’m used to typing fast (over 120 wpm) due to my administrative job at uni, so I can get a page typed in a minute or two.

      As for your query, I’ll have to check my Italian translated text to find out where that Miami scene is. I think it’s somewhere where Candy talks about her new home (with her anohito-guy..) in the UK and she then describes the books and the photos over the fireplace.

      BTW, there are rumours circulating that the CCFS has been translated in French and will be available to the public come this November. Has anyone heard of this or is it just hearsay (and wishful thinking)? I’m still wondering why it hasn’t been translated in English yet..

      • Ms Puddle says:

        Hello Avon and Arwyn,

        I’ll reply to you both later, but for now, I’ve found the passage that Arwyn is asking about:

        It’s in Volume 2 Section 3 right after Candy’s letter to Dr. Frank.

        About French translation, it’s real. However, the publisher changed the book title to “Candice White, l’orpheline”. It’s available in Amazon for pre-ordering I was told.

      • Avon says:

        Hello Arwyn,

        Here’s the “Miami” reference which you’re probably looking for as I did a quick search in Ms Puddle’s archived translations. Please take note that these translations are unofficial and derive from the hard work of many fans, most notably, Fay’s extensive and thorough work:

        [CCFS /Section 3/ Narrative 3]

        https://www.docdroid.net/Vm0Ap0v/ccfs-section-3-narrative-3.pdf#page=2

        Breezing through this narrative, I think it’s noteworthy that George didn’t want to take part in the photoshooting either. Needless to mention that Archie steered clear from it by not showing up at all. Come to think of it, Candy’s refusal may have very little to do with Albert but more to do with her wanting to maintain a considerable distance from that toxic creature-Eliza. Albert seems to be “trolling” and mocking this whole Lagan family attention-seeking circus. Take a look at that section, it’s quite funny.

        Cheers,
        Avon

  8. Avon says:

    Hello,

    In response to Candy’s behaviour in Miami during the aforesaid photoshoot, I think the answer is quite simple really. Throughout the entire story, the reader could get a clear impression that Candy feels awkward being among those belonging to the higher echelons of society. Even though she’s by far a dynamic and resourceful young woman, her inhibitions surrounding social segregation and class differences are evident albeit in a subtle way. Let’s not forget that this story takes place in the early 20th century and gender roles as well as social status were perceived in significantly different ways to our own day and age. Besides, Candy was regarded by the “high” society as an inferior due to her orphan status, female gender and the various accusations hurled against her (i.e. thief by the Lagans, slut-shamed at St Paul’s School, possibly slut-shamed again for having lived with Albert for almost two years..).

    That said, Candy would reasonably be more cautious and possibly feel rather embarrassed when Albert wanted to include her in the family photo. Surely there were tons of rumours about their cohabitation soon after Albert revealed his true identity as WWA, hence, adding even more fuel to Candy’s awkwardness around Albert afterwards, especially if she had begun to understand that her feelings for him were more than she had originally fathomed.

    Moreover, let’s not forget that Candy had displayed similar embarrassment and awkwardness around Anthony and later on when watching Terry play the piano. Remember how shy she was in talking to him because for the first time he looked so “aristocratic” when playing the piano? She had never had any issues being comfortable with Terry when he behaved as a rogue or rebel. However, when she observed him in such an elegant state, she was clearly self-conscious and shy ready to leave the room quietly before Terry noticed her presence and called out to her.

    Without having to refer to or single out a specific segment or chapter from the CCFS, the entire story gradually develops into this understanding that Candy did actually experience issues of self-doubt and some forms of inferiority complex, both of which are utterly understandable given the fact that this young woman had been the recipient of targeted harassment, bullying and belittling by the Lagans and often by Terry himself (although his reasons were different but he did demean her continuously, nonetheless). Such continual abuse inevitably has an indelible effect upon the recipient irrespective of how dynamic and empowered that person is. Candy is a remarkable young woman because of her perseverance, personal integrity and headstrong firmness in overcoming such social stereotypes and abuse. However, Candy is a only human and it’s natural for her and for anyone else to feel down-in-the-dumps from time-to-time.

    Therefore, I wouldn’t be too hard nor baffled by Candy’s refusal to be included in the aforementioned photo. In the Epilogue, she also appears to be rather pissed off at Albert and the two of them do have some “lovers’ quarrels” which are cute for us readers, nevertheless. Albert also had his own insecurities to battle when it came to Candy’s past love interests (especially Terry), so both of them are “even” when it comes to having to wrestle with their own demons. The ending of the story though shows that the two of them overcame their insecurities and decided to unite their lives and focus on their future.

    Looking forward to your next posts, Ms Puddle. Know the feeling when it comes to struggling to find some free-time, so we’ve all got your back on this one!

    • Ms Puddle says:

      Well said, Avon! I certainly agree with you, especially about Candy and Albert dealing with their own demons.

      Indeed in CCFS there is a palpable sense of inferiority complex in Candy’s behavior or thoughts, which are not as pronounced in the manga. I don’t mention the anime because it has diverged from the original story.

      However, I’d like to add to your point about Candy’s awkwardness around Albert because she had realized her own feelings for him. Note that she seemed to have some anger management issues as well when they were alone, and she kept on teasing him as an old man too. One might even think this is out of character, because throughout the story Candy is depicted as a loving and kind lady. To me, this boils down to the sexual tension between the two. There was no way he was a father figure to her, and I don’t know when Albert became aware of her desperate search for him during her trip to Rockstown (because he hung her childish drawing in his office). At any rate, Candy might have been uncomfortable with the people in the high society, but she had the guts to decline Granduncle’s order. Even Sarah Lagan did not dare to disobey him, so I’m sure Candy’s actions must have raised some people’s eyebrows back then. 😄

      Thank you for your understanding, Avon. I’ll try to post something either tonight or tomorrow. 💕

  9. Arwyn says:

    Hi! Long time Albert fan here, loving your blog! I am trying to find the place in the CCFS where Candy is with Albert in Miami, they are about to take a group photo, but although Albert wants Candy by his side, Candy goes next to the servants. I need to read the whole chapter to understand Candy’s behavior. Have you discussed this before? I also twitted this to you, as MomentsOfTransition.
    Your blog has been a sight for sore eyes, I must tell you. I come from the bunch of old Albert-fans who got terribly flamed back in 2007-2011. I left two Candy forums and ultimately the fandom itself after having enough. From time to time though, my fondness for Albert makes me look back on his story. Oh, yeah, I’m his fan, not even Candy’s really. 😛

    • Ms Puddle says:

      Hello Arwyn, thanks for your kind words and encouragement. I honestly need it, especially because I can’t even find time to update anymore. 😭

      About that particular passage in CCFS, I don’t remember if I have discussed it in length. Likely not. Sorry I missed your tweet about this. 😅

      Yet I agree this part of Candy’s retrospection has baffled many fans, even those who are fond of Albert like me. That being said, I could see things differently after reading many other sections in the book.

      In a nutshell, I see this as Candy’s implicit message to Albert — that she didn’t want to associate with him as his adopted daughter in public. It’s normal for family members to take pictures standing next to each other, you know. Imagine the reactions of those around them when Candy openly refused Granduncle William’s direct order. He must be one of the most important guests present, and his adoptive daughter rather stand among the servants, reminding everyone once again of her origin (that same night Sarah Lagan admitted the false accusations and cleared Candy’s name).

      Just my two cents, of course. I have written something along this line in my fanfic Peculiar Relationship, fyi. 😊

  1. July 21, 2018

    […] Yes, that’s how Candy ended her letter. In most cases, the highlighted word means “however”, “but”, etc. Yet, this can also be a colloquial way to express the speaker’s emotions or feelings. If you like, you can read this long post by Maggie Sensei, in which she explained with lots of real life examples that when one can’t see the contrast coming or it doesn’t lead to anything contradicting, the word is added to either emphasize the feelings or soften the speech, which is exactly the case here. Candy ended her letter with feelings, that she indeed wanted her spell to work — her Prince on the Hill would take a holiday to come to Pony’s Home on her birthday to spend time with her. 💖 For next post, please click here. […]

I would like to hear from you!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Translate »
%d bloggers like this: